The Toledo Blade Online
The Toledo Blade OnlineThe Toledo Blade Green Edition
Click here to subscribe or renew!
Temp: 39°
Humidity: 88%
Saturday, 11/21/09
Home »   Latest News »   State » 

Click to Receive RSS Feeds!EmailPrint IndexHelp FacebookMySpaceDiggDel.icio.usFark

Article published May 28, 2005
THE COIN FUND
Audit didn't locate $7M in inventory
Ohio Gov. Bob Taft leaves a conference room in the Statehouse after speaking to reporters about Ohio's rare-coin investment.
( THE BLADE/ALLAN DETRICH )

COLUMBUS - Auditors reviewing the inventory of Tom Noe's $50 million state-funded rare-coin venture in September reported to the Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation that nearly $7 million worth of coins could not be observed because they were "not on site," according to complete copies of the inventory released last night.

It is unclear why the bureau took no action to verify the existence of the "off-site" coins.

Bureau spokesman Jeremy Jackson did not return a call seeking comment last night. Mr. Noe also did not return a message.

The Ohio Attorney General's Office, on behalf of the bureau, last night released complete and unredacted copies of the inventories of Mr. Noe's state-funded coin ventures to The Blade.

The newspaper sued the bureau in the Ohio Supreme Court for the documentation earlier this month after bureau officials refused to release complete records, saying the records could reveal trade secrets.

The bureau released the records a day after the Maumee coin dealer's lawyers acknowledged that $10 million to $12 million of the state's assets had been misappropriated from the Noe coin funds.

Law enforcement cruisers and storage trucks surround Tom Noe's rare-coin and collectibles business in Monclova Township, where officers continued removing items yesterday.
( THE BLADE/DIANE HIRES )
"Given recent developments and findings with respect to the inaccuracy of holdings of Capital Coin Funds One and Two," Deputy Attorney General Audra Osmena DeVictor wrote, "any argument that the funds may have had in that such inventories contain trade secrets the release of which would significantly reduce the value of the coins has been greatly diminished."

The inventories contained hundreds of pages listing coins, their grades, values, and serial numbers. The audit did not include Mr. Noe's other investments with state money, which the bureau has said included loans, mortgages, and collectibles such as trading cards, paintings, and autographs.

Coins listed in the inventory ranged from an 1891 10-cent piece valued at $11 to a 1907 $20 coin valued at $1.7 million. Hundreds of coins listed were valued at more than $1,000.

The audits, conducted by Plante & Moran and Doyle & McDonnell in June and reported back to the bureau in September, noted that about 20 percent of the coins held in both Capital Coin Funds could not be observed because they were off site.

Bill Schlosser, who wanted to check on his investments with Tom Noe, is surrounded by journalists in the parking lot of Mr. Noe’s Monclova Township business, Vintage Coins & Collectibles.
( THE BLADE/DIANE HIRES )

According to the procedures noted in the audit, "For coins/packages listed but not on site for inspection, we performed no further procedures to verify the existence of the coin/packages." Coins said to be not on site "can include coins located at a grading company, coins located at a customer's location pending approval, coins out on consignment, etc," the auditors wrote.

The bureau told The Blade for weeks that Mr. Noe had turned over $13.3 million in investment returns since 1998. But they acknowledged two weeks ago that Mr. Noe was allowed to reinvest $5.4 million of the state's share of the reported returns, expanding Ohio's investment in the Noe coin funds to $55.4 million.

State Sen. Marc Dann, a Democrat from suburban Youngstown who also sued the bureau after being refused public records about the rare-coin investment, said last night that problems with the audit were obvious.

"This is exactly the red flag that should have brought [state Auditor Betty Montgomery] to come crashing down on the bureau and make a call to the attorney general to take dramatic action to protect the money," Mr. Dann said.

The Blade learned from a redacted version of the audit last month that 119 coins worth $93,000 could not be accounted for from the fund's Colorado office, and that fund managers said a former employee had possibly stolen the coins.

The Blade also has reported that two coins valued at $300,000 were reported stolen in the mail at the Colorado office.

Blade Staff writers James Drew, Mike Wilkinson, and Christopher D. Kirkpatrick contributed to this report.

Contact Steve Eder at:
seder@theblade.com
or 419-724-6728.


Permanent Link

Cops/Courts
Updated: 7:31 pm
Convenience store robbed in North Toledo >>
State
Updated: 7:30 pm
Ohio sues big credit rating units over losses >>
Blade Area
Updated: 7:30 pm
Skeldon could get buyout >>
Politics/Elections
Updated: 7:30 pm
McNamara to explore running for Ohio Senate >>
Blade Area
Updated: 7:31 pm
Swine flu claims Wood County man >>
Cops/Courts
Updated: 4:43 pm
Woman, 21, gets 13 years for killing >>
More news stories
 



click here!

ADVERTISING SECTIONS
Tom Henry
Updated: 7:48 am
Denial, rush to judgment cloud debate over climate >>

S. Amjad Hussain
Updated: 4:26 am
Muslims must do more than condemn acts of violence >>

Marilou Johanek
Updated: 5:58 am
In a dog's life, there's nothing to worry about >>

Jack Kelly
Updated: 6:26 am
Obama’s vendetta >>

Jack Lessenberry
Updated: 5:56 am
Granholm's shortsighted rhetoric on China hurts state >>

Rose Russell
Updated: 6:24 am
The food you waste could feed hungry people  >>

David Shribman
Updated: 6:34 am
Abortion, not public option, imperils reform >>

Mike Sigov
Updated: 6:26 am
GM acted wisely by hitting brakes on Russian deal >>

Tom Walton
Updated: 5:00 am
Young adult binge drinking nothing to slough off >>

More columnist stories
MOST READ STORIES
1.  2 men slain in 13 hours; killers remain at large
2.  Convenience store robbed in North Toledo
3.  Swine flu claims Wood County man
4.  Skeldon could get buyout
5.  Obama’s vendetta
6.  Woman, 21, gets 13 years for killing
7.  Ottawa Hills resident sues over council speech
8.  Ex-pastor injured in Oct. crash dies
9.  Ohio sues big credit rating units over losses
10.  Humane Society seeks help in burned-cat case
MOST E-MAILED STORIES
1.  Owens failed to address shortcomings in nursing
2.  BGSU plans for 2 new dormitories
3.  Buckeyes sport retro look of 1954
4.  Owens students get apology for lost accreditation
5.  Toledo fares poorly in survey
6.  Skeldon says he will step down Dec. 31, but Konop wants him dismissed immediately
7.  Ex-OSU coach Bruce instills passion for rivalry
8.  Company outlines $37.5M port plan
9.  Chrysler boosts Dundee plant; engine line to gain jobs, add output
10.  Owens faculty vote no confidence in provost


AP  News Headlines



AP  Business Headlines



AP  Sports Headlines


AP  Features Headlines
Copyright 2009 The Blade. By using this service, you accept the terms of our privacy statement and our visitor agreement. Please read them.
The Toledo Blade Company, 541 N. Superior St., Toledo, OH 43660, (419) 724-6000
To contact a specific
department or an individual person, click here.
The Toledo Times ®