The Toledo Blade Online
The Toledo Blade OnlineThe Toledo Blade Green Edition
Click here to subscribe or renew!
Temp: 25°
Humidity: 92%
Tuesday, 02/09/10
Click Here Click Here Click Here Click Here Click Here
Home »   Opinion »   Editorials » 


Click to Receive RSS Feeds!EmailPrint IndexHelp FacebookTwitterDiggDel.icio.usFark

Article published September 25, 2006
More deadly questions

When Kimveer Gill opened fire earlier this month at a junior college in Montreal, Canada, killing one person and wounding 19 others, it was a bloody reminder that the Columbine killings of 1999 still resonate.

Yet we seem no closer to understanding what motivates Columbine killers Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, or Gill, or the teens who plotted to attack a Kansas high school on the seventh anniversary of Columbine, or another teen from North Carolina who killed his father and fired on his former high school after e-mailing the principal at Columbine. Teens in Wisconsin were arrested two weeks ago for allegedly plotting a Columbine-like killing spree.

What pushes them from feeling as outsiders - surely an emotion experienced by innumerable teens and young adults - to taking up arms and opening fire on innocent students?

One student at Montreal's Dawson College, where the recent shootings took place, said authorities should have recognized Gill's potential for violence after reading his Web postings. Those postings, on a Goth Web site, were transparently violent and malevolent. But are they reason enough for police to pull him in for questioning?

Stifling such postings because they could be a prelude to acts of violence places an onerous burden on the operators of such sites. How can they differentiate between harmless ramblings and murderous threats? The operators of the site on which Gill left his postings reject any responsibility and say there's no evidence the Web site influenced him.

Likely to draw more attention is the fact that Gill was a fan of an online computer game with the chilling title "Super Columbine Massacre."

There is argument over whether that and other such games, in which startling violence is perpetrated, contribute to real-life acts. Georgia Tech professor Ian Bogost says people like Gill don't kill because of what they read, hear, or play. How can we be sure without getting inside their minds?

The game's creator also disavows any responsibility for the actions of Gill, claiming that the game's purpose is actually to give insight into the Columbine killers. But that's an entirely disingenuous argument that barely merits consideration. And it doesn't get the game's creators off the hook. A game in which players take on the roles of the Columbine killers doesn't bring psychic insight, just a sick vicarious thrill.

At what point do some video games cease being entertainment and start being incitement to violence? How far should authorities go in monitoring Web sites and acting on postings that suggest the possibility of actual violence? Gill lived with his parents - so what can families do to intercede, if anything?

And how can we identify, help, and stop young people for whom the massacre of school children evokes not horror but fascination and emulation?


Permanent Link

 RECENT RELATED ARTICLES

School-tax case not made | 02/07/2010
Oscar's 10-best nominees | 02/07/2010
A constitutional chance | 02/07/2010
Nigeria lacks leadership | 02/02/2010
Salinger’s legacy | 02/02/2010
Hope dawns in Sri Lanka | 02/01/2010
Calhoun's heirs | 02/01/2010
Uncontested primaries | 02/01/2010
Wishing for snow days | 01/31/2010
Keeping eyes on the road | 01/31/2010
Ohio's poverty report | 01/31/2010
From hero to zero | 01/30/2010
Digital research | 01/30/2010
GM's promising new boss | 01/30/2010
Holy war | 01/26/2010

More related articles »


Blade Area
Updated: 6:18 pm
Weather check, radar and roads
RADAR / FORECAST / CAMS >>
Nation/World
Updated: 6:18 pm
Cribs recalled after 3 deaths >>
State
Updated: 6:18 pm
Weather-related crashes kill 2 on Michigan freeways >>
Accidents/Vehicular
Updated: 6:17 pm
U.S. 24 traffic rerouted, I-75 backed up >>
Blade Area
Updated: 6:17 pm
Toledo officials given raises up to 26.9% >>
Nation/World
Updated: 5:39 pm
Transport Canada offers to buy Ambassador Bridge >>
More news stories




ADVERTISING SECTIONS
Tom Henry
Updated: 7:13 am
Playing the odds can help mitigate disasters >>

S. Amjad Hussain
Updated: 5:53 am
France draws line over Muslim women’s dress >>

Marilou Johanek
Updated: 5:54 am
Sense of superiority drove church to 'help' Haitian children >>

Jack Kelly
Updated: 5:42 am
As Democrats schmooze, Obama’s credibility slides  >>

Jack Lessenberry
Updated: 5:32 am
Granholm failed to make case in last Michigan address >>

Rose Russell
Updated: 6:09 am
Even in South Africa, pols' private affairs are people's business >>

David Shribman
Updated: 9:37 am
Love means never saying budget deficit >>

Mike Sigov
Updated: 12:31 pm
Russia's president brings little to the table >>

Tom Walton
Updated: 5:40 am
Apologies in politics are unprecedented >>

More columnist stories
MOST READ STORIES
1.  Disruptions abound as snow piles up
2.  Toledo officials given raises up to 26.9%
3.  Officer says 33 dogs seized from suspected puppy mill
4.  U.S. 24 traffic rerouted, I-75 backed up
5.  Weather check, radar and roads
6.  Northview principal gets words of support
7.  Introducing the new Sports Illustrated cover model, Brooklyn Decker
8.  Movie Gallery chain to shut 7 area stores
9.  Knights' Cromwell steps down
10.  Swiergosz sentenced over police standoff
MOST E-MAILED STORIES
1.  Tennis champ accused of phone harassment
2.  Toledo strip club puts cover charge into quake relief
3.  Mental health agency looks to pare $3.5M from services
4.  Homelessness board votes for outside audit; advocate Ken Leslie safe for now
5.  Sylvania lawyer charged in thefts from 2 clients
6.  'Stagecoach Mary' broke barriers of race, gender
7.  MAC basketball struggles with fall from elite
8.  Clyde plans to generate electricity from trash
9.  Equine devotee faces 42 counts of animal abuse
10.  Students, staff navigate Perrysburg High School halls in wheelchairs


AP  News Headlines



AP  Business Headlines



AP  Sports Headlines


AP  Features Headlines
Copyright 2010 The Blade. By using this service, you accept the terms of our privacy statement and our visitor agreement. Please read them.
The Toledo Blade Company, 541 N. Superior St., Toledo, OH 43660, (419) 724-6000
To contact a specific
department or an individual person, click here.
The Toledo Times ®