MENU
SECTIONS
OTHER
CLASSIFIEDS
CONTACT US / FAQ
Advertisement
Toby Tokes, center, and his wife, Lisa McCrary-Tokes, stand next to a photo of their murdered daughter, Reagan.
1
MORE

Ohio Supreme Court declines to hear Tokes case

THE BLADE

Ohio Supreme Court declines to hear Tokes case

COLUMBUS — The Ohio Supreme Court has declined to hear a lawsuit from family members of deceased Ohio State University student and former Monclova Township resident Reagan Tokes.

Ms. Tokes’ estate is attempting to sue state officials for not properly monitoring Brian Lee Golsby, who kidnapped, robbed, raped, and killed her the night of Feb. 8, 2017, while he was wearing a GPS ankle monitoring device following his release from prison. The victim’s family contends the state’s failure to monitor his GPS device in real time contributed to her death.

In September of 2018, the Ohio Court of Claims determined the state was immune from liability in the case. Judge Patrick M. McGrath found that the state had no special relationship with Ms. Tokes to protect her from Golsby.

Advertisement

The 10th District Court of Appeals in Columbus had also previously dismissed the lawsuit.

The Thomas J. Moyer Ohio Judicial Center building in Columbus.
Jim Provance
Democrats, GOP set sights on state Supreme Court election

The Ohio Supreme Court released an announcement Tuesday declining to accept jurisdiction for the appeal.

Golsby had been released from prison two months before killing Ms. Tokes after completing an unrelated six-year sentence for attempted rape. He was subject to supervision by the Ohio Adult Parole Authority and released into a residential program run by a nonprofit corporation.

His GPS ankle monitor recorded his whereabouts but was not monitored in real time. For days while wearing the monitor, he committed a series of robberies in Columbus immediately leading up to the night he ran into Ms. Tokes at random as she left work at a restaurant not far from the Ohio State campus.

Advertisement

Ms. Tokes was three months shy of her graduation at the time of her death.

Her family has fought for changes to state laws to prevent what happened to Ms. Tokes from happening to anyone else. Last year, state lawmakers enacted sentencing reforms that allow the state to keep some offenders behind bars longer, but her family continues fighting for additional reforms, such as real-time GPS ankle monitoring.

Earlier this year, the Tokes case drew national attention with an episode of Dateline NBC that examined the crime and the perceived holes in Ohio law that played a role in Ms. Tokes’ death.

Currently before lawmakers is House Bill 215, sponsored by Kristin Boggs (D., Columbus) and Rick Carfagna (R., Westerville), which proposes curfew, travel, and other restrictions on those wearing GPS devices as well as a mandate that the state maintain housing for released inmates who are rejected by private halfway houses. Parole officer caseloads would also be reduced.  

Reagan Tokes, former Anthony Wayne High School student, was murdered near Columbus.
Jim Provance
Governor orders rethinking of former inmate tracking

A similar measure, Senate Bill 133, has been introduced in the upper chamber by Sens. Sean O’Brien (D., Cortland) and Nathan Manning (R., North Ridgeville).

First Published August 6, 2019, 1:53 p.m.

RELATED
Reagan Tokes
Jim Provance
State trying to reduce parole officer caseloads
Reagan Tokes, former Anthony Wayne High School and OSU student, was murdered near Columbus.
Jim Provance
Tokes murder to serve as case study for parole reform
Reagan Tokes, former Anthony Wayne High School and current OSU student, murdered near Columbus.
Jim Provance
Widespread GPS may give false sense of security, study says
Lisa McCrary-Tokes and her husband, Toby, have fought for closer monitoring of parolees. 'There’s a false sense of security with the ankle monitoring program as it currently exists, and it’s failing victims every day,' she says.
Jim Provance
'Close the circle of failure,' mother tells lawmakers
Toby Tokes, center, and his wife, Lisa Lisa McCrary-Tokes, stand next to a photo of their murdered daughter, Reagan.
Isaac Flowers
Reagan Tokes case: What you need to know
Toby Tokes, center, and his wife, Lisa McCrary-Tokes, stand next to a photo of their murdered daughter, Reagan.
Isaac Flowers
Reagan Tokes case to be featured on 'Dateline' episode
Reagan Tokes, former Anthony Wayne High School student, was murdered near Columbus.
Jim Provance
Trying again on new parole reforms in wake of Tokes murder
Photos of Reagan Tokes with family and friends are on display at the Rally for Reagan fund-raiser to benefit the Reagan Delaney Tokes Memorial Foundation at The Pinnacle in Maumee on March 15, 2019.
Mike Sigov
Reagan Tokes' legacy lives on through fund-raiser
Lisa McCrary-Tokes, right, gets out of the grasp of her daughter, Makenzie Tokes, 18. Makenzie is the sister, and Lisa is the mother of Reagan Tokes, who was murdered in February, 2017. During the self-awareness/self defense class at the Ohio Martial Arts Center in Maumee last year, students are taught how do defend themselves against predators.
Jay Skebba
Events planned to remember Reagan Tokes, benefit memorial foundation
Reagan Tokes
Jim Provance
House passes 'Reagan Tokes' bill
Toby Tokes, center, and his wife, Lisa McCrary-Tokes, stand next to a photo of their murdered daughter, Reagan.
JIM PROVANCE BLADE COLUMBUS BUREAU CHIEF
Tokes family's lawsuit against state dismissed
SHOW COMMENTS  
Join the Conversation
We value your comments and civil discourse. Click here to review our Commenting Guidelines.
Must Read
Partners
Advertisement
Toby Tokes, center, and his wife, Lisa McCrary-Tokes, stand next to a photo of their murdered daughter, Reagan.  (THE BLADE)  Buy Image
THE BLADE
Advertisement
LATEST local
Advertisement
Pittsburgh skyline silhouette
TOP
Email a Story